The poor beleagured knockdown bollard on the northeast corner of Herkimer and Queen has had quite a ride in a short time.
By Ryan McGreal
Published May 25, 2018
As part of the City of Hamilton's ongoing experimentation to figure out how to calm the dangerous speeding traffic on Queen Street, staff beefed up the pedestrian crossovers (PXO) at Queen and Herkimer with highly visible, neon-green Stop for Pedestrians bollards in April.
From my admittedly anecdotal observation of the intersection and my use as a pedestrian, these knockdown bollards were immediately effective at reducing vehicle speeds and making drivers more alert to the presence of pedestrians trying to cross.
Unfortunately, the bollard on the northeast corner was accidentally placed right in the middle of the Herkimer bike lane, blocking it completely.
Bollard blocking Herkimer bike lane at Queen, April 12, 2018 (RTH file photo)
Fortunately, city staff responded quickly and moved the bollard into the edge line between the bike lane and the car lane.
Bollard moved to correct spot between bike lane and car lane, April 13, 2018 (RTH file photo)
As evidence for why this bollard is necessary to physically demarcate and protect the bike lane, it quickly began to incur damage from cars whose drivers strayed out of the driving lane going through the cockeyed intersection.
By mid-May, it was a hurting unit, cracked in several places and listing to port.
Bollard damaged, May 15, 2018 (RTH file photo)
As of the morning of May 17, it was gone completely.
Bollard missing, May 17, 2018 (RTH file photo)
After another follow-up with the City, the bollard was replaced on May 17 - once again, right in the middle of the bike lane.
Bollard blocking Herkimer bike lane again, May 17, 2018 (Image Credit: Tom Flood)
The City Councillors whose wards flank Queen Street - Aidan Johnson in Ward 1 and Jason Farr in Ward 2, responded quickly to confirm that the situation would be rectified.
City staff came back and removed the bollard completely instead of moving it to its proper position. After still more follow-ups with the City, staff responded that there was no location they could place the bollard that was not inconvenient to cars.
To Councillor Johnson's everlasting credit, he pushed back on this argument, replying: "That it’s inconvenient to cars is exactly the point."
Staff agreed to reinstall it, and sure enough, the bollard was reinstalled again on May 24 - this time back in the correct location.
New bollard installed in correct spot between bike lane and car lane, May 25, 2018 (RTH file photo)
It will be interesting to see what happens to this bollard next!
You must be logged in to comment.