Commentary

Festival of Friends: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly - Updated

Overall, it was a huge success to have the Festival back in Gage Park, but a few issues represent opportunities for improvement next year.

By Ryan Barath
Published August 09, 2017

This article has been updated.

The Good

As we all know by now, Festival of Friends returned to Gage Park this past weekend and was well attended. The overall vibe and excitement in the Gage Park and The Delta West neighbourhood was electric all weekend, with big acts like Terri Clark, Stars, Hollerado and July Talk taking the main stage by storm.

Speaking of storms, even Mother Nature was in a cooperative mood for the duration of the festival other than early Friday evening. Parking was easy and transit was available on a scale that was previously unavailable when the festival was relocated to the Ancaster Fairgrounds a few years ago.

Even as someone who lived near the Ancaster fairgrounds at the time when the Festival first moved there, getting to the grounds either by car or by one of the free shuttles was still a painfully slow journey and one of the reasons I never attended after the first year.

Overall, it was huge success to have Festival of friends back in Hamilton's core and going forward it's easy to see why this continues to be one of the largest free festivals in Ontario.

The Bad

Now to some critical points I'd like to make about the way Festival of Friends managed crowd control and security.

Saturday night was arguably the most popular evening for the festival with headliners July Talk fresh off of their co-sold out show with local heros Arkells at the Budweiser Gardens (previously Molson Canadian Amphitheatre) last month.

My wife and I arrived with lots of time around 8:30 PM. I was surprised by the "walk up" access from all angles to the park, which explains the many people who decided to carry alcohol and beer openly even with a beer garden available. (Sidenote: the beer garden itself had the best security for the whole event.)

Away from the stage, security and police presence felt almost nonexistent with two instances within 15 minutes where a horde of teenagers - probably close to a hundred - stampeded and mobbed around a fight with nobody to break it up or discourage the behaviour. Both times it felt very out of control and in both instances we had to quickly move out of the way to avoid being engulfed.

In the two hours my wife and I were there, we spotted only three police officers in the area of the midway. Obviously this is not the fault of the police who were there, but for an event this scale, the organizers should have taken it upon themselves to have more actual police officers present and less inexperienced volunteers around to help prevent extremely unsafe situations like the ones that occurred.

The Ugly

First off, I'd like to state that overall, the vendors and organizations in attendance were wonderful. (For full disclosure, the organization I work for, PATH Employment, had a booth and the process to get the booth was simple and straightforward.)

But, and it's a big one: in 2017, when companies like Walmart, Amazon, eBay, Target, and many more have completely halted the sale of merchandise with Confederate flags, how is it that Festival of Friends openly allows retailers at their festival to sell this garbage?

Confederate merchandise for sale at Festival of Friends (Image Credit: Jessica Rose/Twitter)
Confederate merchandise for sale at Festival of Friends (Image Credit: Jessica Rose/Twitter)

Seriously, it's called Festival of Friends and their very own Mission Statement says: "To enrich the quality of life by promoting and celebrating all aspects of cultural life; to support artists and cultural groups through programs accessible to all people within Greater Hamilton and beyond."

Nowhere does it say to include the sale of items that represent hate, slavery, and racism. I respect free speech and respect that any individual can be as dumb and racist as they want, but the event organizers have a responsibility to those in attendance to create a welcoming environment and 100 percent stop vendors from selling items that represent hate in our community.

Moving forward, this needs to be addressed as part of the application process and a code of conduct for vendors should be established.


Update: RTH has received an email from Lisa Giulietti, Exhibits Coordinator for the Festival of Friends, clarifying that their policy is not to allow Confederate merchandise to be sold and that they will be following up with the vendor:

Just so you're aware, all vendors are required to give a detailed account of the items they intend to sell. Clearly, any merchandise with the Confederate flag was not on the list. Nor had it been made obvious during set-up. Had it been brought to my attention during the Festival, the items would have been removed. Items containing the Confederate flag are NOT acceptable merchandise.

I will be speaking with this vendor and it will be made clear that no such items will be allowed at the Festival going forward. Depending on the response from this vendor, it is possible an invitation to return will not be extended.

RTH appreciates this response from the Festival organization.

Ryan Barath is the Community Outreach Coordinator at PATH Employment and proud Hamiltonian focused on community and economic growth.

6 Comments

View Comments: Nested | Flat

Read Comments

[ - ]

By KarlAndrus (registered) | Posted August 09, 2017 at 18:59:50

My partner and I got caught in that swarm. At first we saw the waves of recording lite cellphones and assumed it was some kind of star sighting. It took a few moments to notice it was actually a brawl between two young women, and the onlookers where sickeningly recording the sight, following them around like dancing dragons. It was quite a frightening; Left us feeling unsafe and left a bad taste about about the nature of humanity. The screaming too left a lingering impression. It was rather deafening.

Permalink | Context

[ - ]

By NortheastWind (registered) | Posted August 11, 2017 at 11:23:15

I was in the crowd for July Talk. Great band. I carried beer while in the crowd and appreciated the freedom to do so. However I wouldn't dare venture beyond the crowd as I don't need a fine. What happened to the new (2011) Ontario law that allows for alcohol to be carried openly at festivals? Get with the times archaic Hamilton !!

Here's a quote from this CBC article: http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/drink-up-o...

"Festivals and events can now designate larger areas beyond the cramped and sometimes smelly beer tents for people to move around with drinks in hand."

Permalink | Context

[ - ]

By alexsam (registered) - website | Posted August 18, 2017 at 02:15:01

A truly pleasant family-accommodating celebration with a solid and warm hippy vibe. Anticipate that the climate will be laid-back and agreeable and anticipate that the site will be extremely brilliant and diletantish. corporate presentations. There will be a wealth of tipis and yurts, delightful painstaking work, and conceivably a larger number of dreadlocks per square meter than a considerable measure of different celebrations.

Permalink | Context

[ - ]

By rgelder@cogeco.ca (registered) - website | Posted August 21, 2017 at 13:56:31

There was confederate flag merchandise being sold at this past weekend's Cactus festival and Dundas, as well.

I made a complaint to one of the festival organizers in person on Saturday night, we should be that the offending item would be gone in the morning. I have no reason to believe that she didn't follow up.

I hope this is something that festival organizers take seriously, particularly when there is the wild west of often unlicensed vendors. In any event, let those of us with privilege remain vigilant.

Permalink | Context

By rgelder@cogeco.ca (registered) - website | Posted August 21, 2017 at 13:57:00 in reply to Comment 121876

*who assured me

Permalink | Context

[ - ]

By My905Hamilton (registered) - website | Posted August 24, 2017 at 00:07:16

I was there and totally agree with Ryan. I shot some video & titled "Hamilton Festival of Friends 2017 Organized Mob Fight" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XoLTDWU1... I forward the video to the police and they told me there was no incident on Saturday night! Total BS! Here is the reply I got from Hamilton Police:

"My name is Art Lenters. I am the 'Crime Manager' for Division 2 which includes Gage Park. I was involved in the Police aspect of the planning for the Festival of Friends event this year. I have viewed the video that you forwarded. It is difficult for me to determine the elements of the organized mob fight as you describe. It certainly appears to be a crowded location at that time. I do know that there were no major reported incidents for the weekend. Overall, considering the size of the event, things went very well from a policing perspective. We would be interested in investigating any criminal acts that may have occurred, we would need to have potential victims identified, or for involved persons to come forward as complainants for an investigation to begin. If you have any further information on the incident please let me know."

Permalink | Context

View Comments: Nested | Flat

Post a Comment

You must be logged in to comment.

Events Calendar

Recent Articles

Article Archives

Blog Archives

Site Tools

Feeds